| Carbon
exhibits many operational and financial advantages over
metallic materials as a linear current collect4or, and the
benefits to user systems are becoming increasingly apparent
as more of the world's railway, third rail and
tram/trolleybus systems change to carbon.
Overhead current
collection
On pantograph systems, the
advantages of carbon include:
- Longer collector strip
life, with lower maintenance costs and less-frequent
replacement
- Longer wire life, giving
significant reductions in cost of maintenance for the
overhead system
- Reduced mass for better
current collection
- Carbon's inert qualities,
which ensure that carbon will not weld to the conductor
wire - even after long periods of static current loading
- The ability to operate at
high speeds (240km/hour and more)
- The virtual elimination of
electrical interference to telecommunications and signal
circuits
- Negligible audible noise between
rubbing surfaces
Laboratory and field
comparisons between carbon and copper, sintered bronze or
aluminium pantograph collector strips show many examples of
up to tenfold increase in collector and wire life and recent
studies in Japan show a projected 25% saving in total system
operating costs.
Third and fourth rail
systems
Steel, cast-iron, copper or
bronze shoes on third and fourth rail collection systems
inflict mechanical damage to the rail because of their
relatively high mass.
Their high co-efficients of
friction also create excessive wear both to the collector
and the rail. Once wear takes place, electrically-conductive
- and some times magnetic - debris is created so motor
windings and other systems must be protected.
Inevitably sparking between
damaged rail and collector also occurs, causing further
problems of interference to telecommunications and
signalling systems.
The use of carbon-based
collector materials virtually eliminates all these problems.
Carbon's relatively low mass (one third that of copper)
minimises mechanical hammer damage to the rail, and its
self-lubricating properties ensure a patina of carbon is
deposited on the rail reducing friction and wear and almost
completely eliminating sparking.
As an added bonus, the carbon
patina provides a degree of natural de-icing capability.

This photograph shows
the potential vulnerability of modern capped third
rails. |
Carbon is particularly
valuable as a collector material on systems using capped
rails, where the margin for damage is greatly reduced. |

Carbon

Copper

Sintered Metal

Aluminium

These photographs taken under
a microscope show the differing wear characteristics to the
overhead wire from using carbon, copper, sintered metal and
aluminium as a collector material. |